Mystery Bag - Choose from 3 Options

(67 reviews) Write a Review
Cool Bag - Full of Grays and Cool Purples

These mystery bags contain approx. $50 worth of products. Each bag will contain 4 exclusive eye shadow shades and 1 exclusive blush in each bag. The other items may be new or current products. 

Choose from Bright, Cool, or Warm bags. Each option is available in a Deep version for darker skin-tones. 

Each color bag may contain the same items and some may have small variations. The deep versions will have multiple overlaps with the lighter version of the same color option. To avoid duplicates, try different color bags for more of a variety. 

67 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    Gray mystery bag

    Posted by Becky Champ on Feb 17th 2021

    The gray mystery bag (cool, light) is an amazing value! I received 4 single eyeshadows, a cream shadow, a blush, and a loose glitter. The color selections were great- grays, silvers, blue, and purple and a deep rose blush.. The eyeshadows are very smooth and extremely pigmented and the blush is as well. The bag itself is really pretty and sturdy. I will definitely be making more purchases.

  • 5
    Mystery bag

    Posted by Missy Kozubal on Feb 17th 2021

    One of the best mystery bags I have ever purchased. Loved the colors sent to me.

  • 5
    Mystery bag

    Posted by Lee on Feb 16th 2021

    I have only tried the blush and highlighters so far from the mystery bags and they were incredibly awesome! The shadows that were sent look fantastic and I can’t wait to give them a go. I wish I had picked up the colorful one too. I picked up the other two mystery bags and have been super happy. When they come back in stock I might just order the colorful one as well

  • 5
    Bag is good

    Posted by Emma on Feb 16th 2021

    Great value, loved getting eyeshadow, blush and highlight. Loose glitter isn't for me but still worth getting. The bag itself is really nice.

  • 5
    Great value and incredible shadows

    Posted by Sabrina on Feb 16th 2021

    I ordered 2 mystery bags (the warm peach and the colourful fushcia deep ). Both came with such gorgeous shades that I am excited to use.
    The warm peach bag came with 5 single shadows, a loose highlight, a glitter and a blush. The colourful fuschia bag came with 5 single shadows, a loose highlight, a glitter and a cream shadow.
    Super happy with the products so far. The glitters are a bit of a throwaway product for me (or maybe a niece can use it for her dance recitals) but the value for all the other products far outweighs the cost. And the quality of the shadows are AMAZING. This was my first SG purchase but it won't be my last!!!

  • 5
    Warm Peach

    Posted by Heather Theakston on Feb 7th 2021

    I missed out on the Warm Peach bag this summer but I was so excited to see it restocked. The value and quality of the shadows in this color collection are unbelievably beautiful. Sydney Grace formulas are superior to majority of the shadows in my eyeshadow collection.

  • 5
    Excellent value for first time customer

    Posted by Gina on Sep 29th 2020

    I love the eye shadows in this mystery bag. Jeweled tone shimmers and bright colorful mattes. The formula is soft and buttery but it's also pigmented. I also love the loose highlighter, very sparkly. I would say the blush was a surprise. I would definitely buy another of these mystery bags ☺

  • 5
    So Good I Ordered Two

    Posted by Demetria on Aug 14th 2020

    I loved this bag that I ordered another one for my BFF for her birthday!

  • 5
    Mystery Bag

    Posted by Denise on Aug 8th 2020

    I love the Mystery Bags! I bought two of them and they both were beautiful. All of the products performed as you would expect from Sydney Grace and the bags are quality made. I will definitely buy again if offered.